Johnny tomatoes
New york style pizza

Available in 14” medium, 18” extra large, and 24” party pizza sizes.

Also available as a 12” gluten-free cauliflower crust, add $3.

CLASSIC CHEESE $14 $18 $25

Our classic pizza with our signature pizza sauce, mozzarella, grated parmesan, and olive oil.

SPECIALTY NEW YORK STYLE PIZZAS

MARGHERITA PIZZA $18 $22 $29
Crushed Italian tomatoes, fresh mozzarella, fresh basil, grated romano, and olive oil

TRENTON TOMATO PIE $14 $18 $25
A Jersey classic- pizza sauce, plenty of grated romano, fresh basil, and olive oil. No mozz here!

WHITE PIZZA $19 $23 $30
Whipped ricotta, mozzarella, grated romano, fresh garlic cream sauce, and olive oil.

HOLIDAY WHITE PIZZA $20 $24 $31
Our white pizza topped with broccoli, spinach, blistered tomatoes, olive oil, and grated romano cheese.

VODKA PIZZA $20 $24 $31
Our vodka sauce with mozzarella and grated romano cheese. Choose our spicy vodka sauce if you like it hot!

FIAMMA ROSA PIZZA $22 $25 $32
A crowd-pleasing favorite of spicy vodka sauce with mozzarella, cup pepperoni, and Mike's hot honey with fresh basil.

PIZZA GIUDITTA $19 $23 $30
Choose from our cold chopped italian or chopped caesar salad on our classic crust with garlic and olive oil, no tomato sauce.

BUFFALO CHICKEN PIZZA $20 $24 $31
Our own ranch buffalo sauce topped with diced chicken cutlet, mozzarella, and ranch drizzle.

LASAGNA PIZZA $22 $25 $32
Sliced meatballs with whipped ricotta and marinara, grated romano cheese, and olive oil.

THE WORKS $22 $25 $32
Our classic cheese with pepperoni, sausage, bacon, peppers, onions, mushrooms, and black olives.

JOHNNY’s SICILIAN $22

A rectangular 16" large pizza with a thick and soft crust with a slightly crispy bottom, sliced mozzarella, baked upside down with the sauce on top, and romano cheese. Add toppings: $3 per half and $4 per whole.

CALZONE $10

The classic half-moon pizza pocket with ricotta and mozzarella.
Served with a side of marinara.
Add ham or other additional fillings for $1 each.

TOPPINGS

Whole pie: $3 for 14”, $4 for 18”, and $7 for 24”.
Half pie: $2 for 14”, $3 for 18”, and $5 for 24”.

Extra cheese
pepperoni
crumbled sausage
bacon
chicken cutlet
meatballs
cheesesteak
eggplant cutlet
peppers
onions
black olives
ricotta
shaved parmesan
fresh mozzarella
garlic
fresh basil
spinach
broccoli
mushrooms
tomatoes
long hot peppers
Mike’s hot honey

Close-up of pepperoni pizza slices on a baking sheet with a hand holding a pizza cutter in the background.
Pepperoni cheese pizza slices on a wooden serving board with pizza cutter, salt, and grated cheese nearby.
A cheese pizza with tomato sauce, fresh basil, and grated cheese on a cardboard pizza box.
Close-up of a fresh salad pizza topped with lettuce, cherry tomatoes, shredded cheese, and other vegetables.
A stuffed calzone on a wooden surface with a side of tomato sauce and some fresh parsley.